Editor's note: This is the first in a series of updates from Occupy Wall Street, written by Hannah Chadeayne Appel, a postdoctoral scholar at Columbia University's Committee on Global Thought. Photo by Matt McDermott.
Ethnographic Observations from Wall Street
As these details intimate, there is a highly and horizontally organized working structure to the
occupation. Moreover, contrary to some media coverage, there is also shared message among the
thousands. The message is articulated differently, from anarchists to church ladies, union
members to homeless youth, but it is shared. A widely circulated leaflet at the occupation
described the movement as "an otherwise unaffiliated group of concerned citizens who have
come together with the general purpose of holding Wall Street accountable for their fiscal
recklessness and criminal perversion of the democratic process." Citizens at OWS are raising
their voices against the rapacious excesses of the financial system, and the aiding and abetting of
that pillage by our elected officials. For those who believe that language sounds excessive,
consider the 14.2 million home foreclosures that have occurred between 2006 and 2010. Think of
dwindling pension funds, California's public education system, the lavish executive bonuses
juxtaposed to the noose tightening around public services and working people across our
country. In response, Occupy Wall Street offers citizens a space where "the 99%" can begin to
imagine and enact a reinvigorated democracy and a more equitable financial system.
With this openly shared message in mind, is important to push back against the rhetoric
of "disorganization," or "a movement without a message" coming from left, right, and center.
Occupy Wall Street is practicing an ethic of radical democracy: every voice counts and every
action is meaningful. Eschewing hierarchies of charismatic leadership, narrow messaging, or
sound bites, the movement makes room for multiples, and asks that disagreements make room
for one another. The thousands of voices, bodies, minds, and hearts on Wall St. everyday do not
have to agree in any constricted sense in order to be effective. Indeed, space for multiple voices
and multiple concerns defines the movement. It is stronger in its multiplicity.
The process of "occupation" (hundreds of people camped permanently in Zuccotti park) is
modeled explicitly on the occupation of Egypt's Tahrir Square. Zuccotti Park has been renamed
Liberty Park. The movement is overtly international in its influences and scope, and routinely
invokes similar occupations of public space not only in Egypt, but also in Spain, Greece,
Senegal, and elsewhere, where citizens have also been demanding less precarious lives:
affordable education, food, shelter, and health care; the right to a fairly-remunerated livelihood.
Some of the more specific goals of the movement are recognizably liberal and achievable within
our current political economy:
- more progressive taxation policies including a definitive end to the Bush tax cuts;
- new regulation, and renewed enforcement of existing regulation of large banks;
- regulations on the mis-allocation of capital toward speculation and fictitious investment vehicles, steering it toward productive uses in infrastructure, the arts, and other paths that will create employment and the greatest good for the greatest number.
- banning of private campaign finance
- How can we end the false scarcity created in this moment of global financial panic? We CAN afford to build an inclusive society in which all citizens have affordable access to their basic needs. What would that require?
- What would popular control of the financial system look like? How can we democratize economic analysis
- What would it look like for credit unions and cooperative businesses to play a larger role in our economy?
- If you're in New York, come! Talk to people! If you have any flexibility in your schedule, come to New York!
- Wherever you are, please express your support for the movement. Please start conversations about the economic and political environment you would like to live in, and how we can realize that together.
- Donate! Again, the movement is well organized and the Finance Working Group is taking donations to pay for the free food, free medical care, art supplies, and media campaign they prepare and distribute every day. For information on donating money, go to: nycga.cc
- You can also donate goods. As of Tuesday October 11th the items needed most urgently were: sleeping bags; tarps; large umbrellas; first aid; and warm clothing. Please see nycga.cc for mailing details

Leave a comment